Ruh-roh! This week, the gang stumbles across some very overdue Christmas gifts—including custom LEGO doppelgängers that send them down memory lane. But it’s not all bricks and gigg...

Jinkies! Kim’s unearthed a treasure trove of documentaries guaranteed to blow your mystery-loving minds! From lost art and long-lost kids to tech billionaires chasing immortality a...

Zoinks, Gang! Join Josh for a mesmerizing deep dive into the eerie folklore of the Appalachian sirens—those haunting voices said to lure travelers off the beaten path. Are they res...

Zoinks, Gang! In this episode of Mystery Inc, we’re stepping into the smoldering urban legend of The Crying Boy—a mass-produced painting that seemingly refused to burn, no matter h...

Zoinks, Gang—this one’s got more twists than a carnival pretzel! In this episode, Shane investigates the decades-long nightmare of anonymous letters that rocked a small Ohio town. ...

Zoinks, gang—Shane’s off chasing sunshine somewhere, so Josh and Kim are rolling up their sleeves to explore the spooky catacombs under Vatican City! These hidden tunnels hold secr...